Valuentum Exclusive Analysis for the Discerning Investor

Symbol Keyword

P&G and Kimberly-Clark Tell Two Different Stories
Image Shown: Since the beginning of 2019, on a price-only basis, Procter & Gamble (orange) has handily outpaced the Vanguard Consumer Staples ETF while Kimberly-Clark (turquoise) has stumbled. Procter & Gamble’s shares have been on an incredible run the past couple years, with the company driving strong organic revenue and earnings per share growth. Kimberly-Clark, on the other hand, has been executing poorly in a market environment where one might think it should be excelling. Both of these stocks are dividend growth giants, with P&G boasting a 65-year dividend growth track record and Kimberly-Clark stringing together 49 consecutive annual dividend increases. Both also have strong Dividend Cushion ratios of 1.8 at this time, suggesting resilient dividend coverage on a go-forward basis. That said, investors will have to pay up for P&G’s dividend strength and operational tailwinds, as shares are a bit pricey based on our fair value estimate range, and even Kimberly-Clark’s valuation is only slightly more reasonable after its sharp drop following the 2021 earnings guidance cut. We expect to make a few tweaks to our valuation models following their respective calendar first-quarter 2021 reports, but if we had to pick between these two dividend growth behemoths, P&G looks like the better relative play. Shares of P&G yield ~2.6%, while shares of Kimberly-Clark yield 3.3%.

General Mills Prepares for Cost Inflation, Pet Business Growing Rapidly
Image Source: General Mills Inc – Third Quarter of Fiscal 2021 IR Earnings Presentation. On March 24, General Mills posted third quarter earnings for fiscal 2021 (period ended February 28, 2021) that beat consensus top- and bottom-line estimates on a GAAP basis, though its adjusted non-GAAP bottom-line performance missed consensus estimates. General Mills has seen demand surge higher for its products in the wake of the coronavirus (‘COVID-19’) pandemic as households stockpiled goods and started eating at home more often. The company posted a solid fiscal third quarter earnings report, though its outlook is facing headwinds as General Mills is contending with cost inflation concerns. Shares of GIS yield ~3.4% and are trading just above our fair value estimate as of this writing, after selling off in the wake of its latest earnings report.

Mondelez Capturing Share, Generating Strong Free Cash Flow
Image Source: Mondelez International Inc – November 2020 IR Presentation. On January 28, snacks giant (generates most of its annual revenues from biscuits, chocolates, gum and candy) Mondelez International reported fourth quarter earnings for 2020 that beat both consensus top- and bottom-line estimates. Management noted in the earnings press release that the firm “enter[ed] 2021 in a strong position financially and in the marketplace which gives us confidence that we can deliver on our long-term growth targets in 2021 and beyond.” Mondelez reported 3.7% net organic revenue growth in 2020, supported by favorable volume and pricing movements, and negatively impacted by product mix. The firm’s GAAP revenues were up just under 3% year-over-year in 2020, held down by foreign currency headwinds.

Procter & Gamble Remains a Great Free Cash Flow Generator
Image Shown: Shares of Procter & Gamble Co have started to shift back down towards the top end of our fair value estimate which sits at $120 per share of PG. In our view, investors have begun to factor in expectations that the firm’s growth rate of late will be incredibly hard to sustain over the coming years. Procter & Gamble is a solid company with great free cash flow generating abilities, but the run up in its share price during the second half of the 2020 calendar year was a tad overdone, in our view. On January 20, Procter & Gamble reported solid earnings for the second quarter of fiscal 2021 (period ended December 31, 2020) as its GAAP revenues grew by 8% year-over-year while its GAAP operating income climbed higher by 20%, aided by economies of scale and GAAP gross margin expansion. The company reported strong organic sales growth across all of its core product categories, with its ‘Fabric & Home Care’ and ‘Health Care’ products leading the way. Pricing strength combined with organic volume growth and a favorable product mix played a big role in boosting Procter & Gamble’s margins. It appears consumers are willing to pay up for its products, which tend to be the more expensive items in supermarkets, grocery stores, convenience stores, and similar venues. Looking ahead, Procter & Gamble increased its guidance for fiscal 2021. P&G forecasts it will post annual sales growth (on both a net and organic basis) of 5%-6% and annual diluted EPS growth of 8%-10% this fiscal year, underpinned by its strong performance during the first half of fiscal 2021.

Target Reaches All-Time Highs
Image Shown: Shares of Target Corporation are now trading near their all-time highs as of this writing. Shares of Target Corp recently reached an all-time high after the company reported third quarter earnings for fiscal 2020 (period ended October 31, 2020) on November 18 that smashed past consensus estimates on both the top- and bottom-lines. During its latest earnings report, Target reported that its comparable store sales rose by 20.7% year-over-year with digital comparable sales up 155% during this period. During the first nine months of fiscal 2020, Target generated over $5.0 billion in free cash flow. The top end of our fair value estimate range sits at $182 per share, and as of this writing, shares of TGT are trading near $172, indicating Target appears fairly valued at this time. Shares of TGT yield a decent ~1.6% as of this writing, and we give Target a “GOOD” Dividend Safety rating given its impressive cash flow profile.

Walmart’s Digital Strategy Continues to Pay Off
Image Shown: Walmart Inc continues to distribute its free cash flows back to shareholders via dividends and share repurchases. The retailing giant’s management team has a long track record of being shareholders friendly. However, we still view shares of WMT as generously valued as of this writing, given that the top end of our fair value estimate range sits at $133 per share though WMT is currently trading closer to ~$150 per share. Image Source: Walmart Inc – Third Quarter of Fiscal 2021 IR Earnings Presentation. On November 17, Walmart reported third quarter earnings for fiscal 2021 (period ended October 31, 2020) that beat consensus estimates on both the top- and bottom-lines. As we have noted in the past, the key driver behind Walmart’s financial outperformance of late has been its e-commerce operations. Whether that be to support home delivery services or curbside pick-up options, Walmart’s past digital investments better allowed the retailing giant to meet surging demand for consumer staples and other products in the wake of the ongoing coronavirus (‘COVID-19’) pandemic. The top end of our fair value estimate range sits at $133 per share of WMT, indicating Walmart is generously valued as of this writing as its shares are currently trading near $150. However, we still view Walmart’s business model as stellar and its cash flow profile as impressive. During the first nine months of fiscal 2021, Walmart generated over $16.4 billion in free cash flow. The firm spent $4.6 billion covering its dividend obligations and another $1.2 billion buying back its stock during this period, and both of these activities were fully covered by Walmart’s free cash flows and then some. Shares of WMT yield ~1.4% as of this writing.

Kraft Heinz Shows the Power of the VBI
Image: Years ago, shares of Kraft Heinz registered a rating of 1 on the Valuentum Buying Index (VBI) on two separate occasions, highlighting the company’s overpriced nature and weakening technicals. Rare and extreme ratings on the VBI, 1 = worst; 10 = best, tend to be the most informative and/or the most actionable for investors. There are just too many net cash rich, free cash flow generating powerhouses with tremendous competitively advantaged business models tied to secular growth tailwinds that taking a flier on an overleveraged turnaround such as Kraft Heinz almost feels irresponsible. That said, shares yield ~5.2% as of this writing, so income investors might find a decent risk reward at the right price. With a 27% stake, Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway seems to think so.

Our Thoughts on Philip Morris International’s Latest Earnings Report
Image Shown: Philip Morris International Inc has been able to maintain its global market share in the tobacco industry while pushing through price increases as indicated by its relatively strong ‘Combustible Tobacco Pricing’ performance seen through the first nine months of 2020. Image Source: Philip Morris International Inc – Third Quarter of 2020 IR Earnings Presentation. Tobacco giant Philip Morris reported third quarter 2020 earnings on October 20 which saw the company beat both consensus top- and bottom-line estimates. Philip Morris International also raised its full-year guidance for 2020 in part due to industry volumes holding up better than expected in Indonesia, which raised the minimum selling price for cigarettes while also increasing cigarette taxes at the start of 2020. For the full-year, the company now expects to generate $5.03 - $5.08 in GAAP diluted EPS (up from $4.84 - $4.99 previously) and $5.37 - $5.42 in non-GAAP adjusted diluted EPS (up from $5.23 - $5.38 previously). Philip Morris International continued to maintain its ~28-29% market share (excluding China and the US) of the global tobacco industry in the third quarter. Additionally, the firm has been able to also push through price increases versus year-ago levels. We continue to like shares of Philip Morris International as a holding in our High Yield Dividend Newsletter portfolio. Shares of PM yield ~6.4% as of this writing on a forward-looking basis after the firm raised its quarterly dividend by roughly 3% in September.

PepsiCo Earnings Update
Image Shown: PepsiCo Inc’s expansive snacks and beverage portfolio is home to 23 brands that generated $1+ billion in annual retail sales in 2019. We are big fans of PepsiCo’s business model but caution that the firm’s net debt load needs to be closely monitored going forward, especially given management’s generous approach to dividends and share repurchases. Image Source: PepsiCo Inc – CAGNY 2020 IR Presentation. PepsiCo reported third-quarter fiscal 2020 earnings (period ended September 5, 2020) that beat both top- and bottom-line consensus estimates. PepsiCo’s organic revenue growth, a non-GAAP metric, stood out. During the fiscal third quarter and the first three quarters of fiscal 2020, PepsiCo’s organic revenue growth clocked in at 4.2% and 3.6%, respectively, on a year-over-year basis. For the full fiscal year, management is guiding for ~4% annual organic sales growth at PepsiCo. In May 2020, PepsiCo increased its quarterly dividend, and the firm was happy to announce that this marked its 48th consecutive year of annual dividend increases. PepsiCo has paid out quarterly dividends since 1965 and remains very committed to rewarding its shareholders. Organic sales growth will provide a tremendous amount of support to PepsiCo’s cash flows going forward.

Kroger Fighting for Market Share in the Online US Grocery Business
Image Source: The Kroger Company – Fiscal 2019 Annual Report. On June 18, The Kroger released its first quarter fiscal 2020 earnings (period ended May 23, 2020) that beat both top- and bottom-line estimates. Comparable store sales (excluding fuel) grew by 19% year-over-year as consumers flocked to its various grocery stores and supermarkets (under brands such as Fred Meyer, Fry’s Marketplace, Pick ‘n Save, and others) to stock up on consumer staples products as the coronavirus (‘COVID-19’) spread across North America. Kroger’s digital sales surged 92% year-over-year last fiscal quarter as curbside and home delivery options have become increasingly popular during the pandemic. Shares of KR yield ~2.0% and are trading in the upper bound of our fair value estimate range as of this writing.